Features
Open

Cooking Rework: The Journey of an Insane Grindfest

I don't like lengthy grindfests, however, my guildie doesn't mind them. We had a lengthy, heated discussion however. And I think we came to a resolution...

Cooking needs a rework.

Currently, the grind of leveling cooking is insane. I don't know the exact figures, but I roughly cooked 400 raw meats, using 2 rather than 3 per cook, as it rewards the same amount of experience, regardless, I gained 10 Levels in Cooking. Yes, that is maths'ing at 20,000 raw meat to hit level 500 cooking. That is a grindfest indeed.

My suggestion, this is going to be lengthy, is:

Reduce the base experience gained from cooking. (I know, sounds dumb, but we need to balance out the buffs coming up)

When you cook something, you combine raw materials and create a 'dish', things like Campfire Pottage, Seared Fillet and Coalfire Skewer. These should be unlocked into a recipe book, you keep the combination campfire creator, but that's only used for discovering dishes, perhaps discovering a new dish could give some decent experience as it's a one-time event.

When you have the dish discovered, you can cook it from the recipe book. (This would be a separate tab within the cooking menu) The recipe book will give descriptions for each dish, so the player can see which dishes give which bonus effects. For example, Coalfire Skewer gives +strength and Seared Fillet gives +vitality.

Now for the deepness, lets get intense. Each dish has its own level, you're no longer just leveling cooking, you're leveling individual dishes too. As you level up the dish, it increases the cooking experience that it yields, and of course, for those not following. You gain experience for the dish whenever you cook that dish. That means that you will level each dish individually.

Not only does leveling up the dishes increase the cooking experience they yield, but it also levels them up into being better forms of themselves. Currently you can get different qualities of food from the amount of raw material used. I think those qualities should be gated behind the dish level, rather than how many raw materials are used.

To further this Chef adventure, once a player hits 500 Cooking, they should be able to specialise into a Master Cooking direction. I'm thinking things like Stew Master, Grill Master, Sear Master, etc etc. Choosing a direction will allow the player to be a master of 1 type of cooking, Stew would be mixing pots of stews and soups, Grill would be meats and Sear would be fish. It obviously wouldn't lock the player out of the basic recipes, but instead would unlock advanced recipes for their chosen style of cooking.

I think currently cooking is too long of a grind without a good enough reward to make the grind feel worthwhile. I don't mind a grind, if it feels rewarding, but currently it's just 'number go up'.

2 Comments

Sign in to comment

C
Cheese
Cheese·1 month ago

Thank you to Lunk for the 2 rather 3 tech, if you don't change anything, please don't patch that.

L
Lunk
Lunk·25 days ago

As far as I can tell, it purely seems to depend on which tier of cooking the food becomes. The idea is to use the least amount of ingredients for the highest tier of output.

If adding an additional ingredient does not increase the tier, then it is effectively doubly wasted; you will have less ingredients for skilling up, and it doesn't gain you any extra skill experience.